The Cleveland Guardians have been fairly inactive during the early stages of the 2026-27 off-season. It’s certainly a stark contrast to what the rest of the AL Central has done to this point.
The Kansas City Royals traded for Bryce Miller, the Minnesota Twins signed Sonny Gray, the Chicago White Sox added Dustin May, and the Detroit Tigers brought in Emilio Pagan. All the Guardians’ division foes acquired pitching help in the still-young offseason. What will Cleveland do, though?
While it’s true that most of their core is already set for 2027 and beyond, team insider Joe Noga is worried that the Guardians have become so used to trying to bring in people at a discount that they won’t even look at better, more expensive alternatives.
“My big issue right here is are we getting too comfortable with the Guardians shopping in the clearance aisle when it comes to adding pieces here while their division rivals are going out there and making bigger moves and making headline moves during this offseason,” Noga said.
The Guardians trust their approach and philosophy, and it’s hard not to when it has yielded eight trips to the playoffs in the last 11 seasons. However, it’s hard to ignore how the division is improving, and Cleveland is standing still.
Right now, the Guardians haven’t seen a deal they liked enough to invest money or prospects, which is fair since their current roster went to the AL Championship Series just a few weeks ago. However, the fear is that they will miss out on some worthwhile opportunities because they refuse to consider moves and deals outside their usual range.
It’s still early, and Guardians’ President of Baseball Operations Chris Antonetti can still get to work. It’s impossible to ignore that the looming lockout will eventually get in the way, though, and Cleveland might be frozen for a few weeks or months before transactions are allowed again.
Only time will tell if Noga is overreacting or if his concerns are valid and logical. For now, he has reasons to be worried, mainly because the AL Central is getting better and making win-now moves. At some point, Cleveland will have to make things happen.
NEXT: 2 Moves The Guardians Must Make This Offseason








