The Cleveland Guardians seem to have the same needs every offseason, and this time around is no different. After falling just a couple of wins short of reaching the World Series, it’s clear that this team still needs a little more juice on offense after scoring just 11 runs over the final five games of the ALCS after plating seven runs in Game 1.
Unfortunately, if the Guardians are going to make any upgrades, they’re going to have to let go of some familiar faces. The tough decisions have started already with the Guardians having decided to non-tender utility-man David Fry, which hurts even more considering it happened on his 31st birthday.
Cleveland.com’s Joe Noga wrote about the decision recently and shed some light on the situation. He noted that with his offensive struggles piling up and the injuries complicating his future, the team just couldn’t justify keeping a spot for him.
“But the version of Fry who returned from surgery never fully recaptured that production. His comeback in 2025 was complicated by the restrictions on his throwing arm, and his offensive struggles continued into 2026. Without the same offensive impact, and with his defensive versatility diminished, Fry became increasingly difficult to fit into Cleveland’s roster construction,” Noga wrote.
It’s not terribly surprising that Fry’s breakout 2024 campaign turned out to be a bit of a fluke. He has been atrocious at the plate over his 330 at-bats in the past two years, aside from the 16 homers. Even though his tenure is ending with a whisper, he’ll forever be cemented in team history for those two massive home runs in the 2024 playoffs, most notably the two-run walk-off in Game 3 of the ALCS against the New York Yankees.
Fry’s power will get him signed elsewhere, but the Guardians need more certainty in 2027. Jo Adell’s presence crowded the outfield room a little bit, and with Fry exiting, the youth movement is in full effect.
The front office could look to find someone on the open market to replace Fry’s versatility because that’s the one thing nobody else on this roster is truly capable of. There aren’t a lot of players like him, and Guardians Nation wishes him all the best wherever he winds up landing next.
NEXT: 2 Guardians Players To Be Concerned About In 2027








