On his 31st birthday, the Cleveland Guardians decided not to tender utilityman and 2024 postseason hero David Fry a contract for the 2027 campaign. He is now free to sign with any MLB team of his liking and is no longer part of the organization.
The decision comes as a mild surprise, given the fact that his projected salary for the 2027 campaign was around $2 million. However, it’s not a complete shock given the way the last two campaigns have gone for him.
“The Guardians have non-tendered David Fry. They reached one-year deals with Matt Festa, Colin Holderman, and Blake Perkins to avoid arbitration. Tendered contracts to remaining arbitration-eligible and pre-arb players on the 40-man roster (now at 39 players),” Guardians insider Tim Stebbins posted.
The Guardians have non-tendered David Fry.
They reached one-year deals with Matt Festa, Colin Holderman and Blake Perkins to avoid arbitration.
Tendered contract to remaining arb eligible and pre-arb players on 40-man roster (now at 39 players).
— Tim Stebbins (@tim_stebbins) November 20, 2026
Fry made his MLB debut with the Guardians in 2023 and had his best season in 2024, when he went to the All-Star Game, hit 14 home runs, drove in 51 runs, and posted a 129 wRC+. After that postseason, which included a signature moment against the New York Yankees in the AL Championship Series, he underwent major elbow surgery and took months to recover.
Fry was limited to DH duties upon returning in 2025 and posted a 62 wRC+ in 157 plate appearances in the majors. Cleveland thought that perhaps he needed a year to regain his swing and his strength, but the utilityman was also a below-average hitter in 2026 with a 93 wRC+ in 214 trips to the plate.
Fry was optioned to Triple-A in early August, after the trade deadline and the acquisitions of Jo Adell and Nathaniel Lowe. He was recalled a few days later, but couldn’t convince the Guardians to keep him around.
Fry, in all likelihood, won’t spend too much time without a job. His ability to hit left-handers and his defensive versatility make him an appealing option for clubs looking for cheap depth. Cleveland, however, wouldn’t give him a roster spot or a modest raise, so he’s now free to sign with anyone.
Cleveland tendered contracts to all their remaining arbitration-eligible players, as well as their pre-arbitration personnel. Fry was the only one who received bad news ahead of Friday’s deadline.
His teammates will surely miss him, as he was one of the most popular guys in the clubhouse.
NEXT: Analyst Says Young Guardians Player Has MVP Potential








