Cleveland Guardians closer Cade Smith came very close to winning the inaugural edition of the AL Reliever of the Year award, losing to Louis Varland of the Toronto Blue Jays in a tight vote. Many people believe he deserved the honor, but his Jays counterpart was equally impressive and a deserving winner.
Despite missing out on that award, there could be more coming for the overpowering righty. Joe Noga of Cleveland.com pointed out that there’s one in particular in which Smith should be a lock to win: the Tip O’Neill award, handed out by the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame to honor the top Canadian-born player in the MLB.
Per Noga, there’s a character component to the award that, in addition to Smith’s long list of accomplishments in 2026, makes him very hard to beat.
“If that’s a consideration, Cade Smith should win this award running away. We’ve been around him a lot and seen the way that he interacts with his teammates and just his commitment and dedication,” Noga said.
Josh Naylor, Smith’s former teammate on the Guardians, was the last winner of the Tip O’Neill award in 2025. Smith should be considered the favorite at this point, having carried Cleveland’s bullpen both in the regular season and the playoffs.
Smith posted a brilliant 1.95 ERA in 74 regular-season frames, striking out 107 batters. It’s the third straight campaign in which he fans at least 100 hitters, a very impressive achievement for a reliever.
Then, Smith was even better in October, under the bright lights and the pressure associated with decades without a World Series trophy. His 2.38 ERA in 11.1 innings doesn’t do justice to how dominant he was at times. He walked just two and struck out 14, becoming a key cog during the Guardians’ deep postseason run.
It’s hard to think about a Canadian baseball player with a more impressive season than Smith. He could become the first reliever to win the award since Jordan Romano in 2022.
The voting process ends on Friday, and the results will be announced in early December.
NEXT: Guardians' Potential Backup Catcher Starts New Winter League Adventure








