The Cleveland Guardians face their first big roster deadline of the offseason on Friday. That is when teams must decide whether to tender contracts to their arbitration-eligible players, and any player who does not receive an offer becomes a free agent. Most of Cleveland’s decisions are straightforward, but the price tags on a few players have sparked some debate. One of the most expensive names on the list is Jo Adell, who is projected to earn about $9.6 million. Joe Noga did not hesitate to say what the Guardians should do with Adell when the topic came up.
“There’s no way, there’s no reasonable way they can not tender Jo Adell a contract,” Noga said.
It is not hard to see why some fans might wonder. A $9.6 million salary would be a sizable chunk of a payroll that came in at about $74.5 million this season, the lowest in baseball. Adell’s overall numbers also were not flashy. Across his time with the Angels and Guardians, he hit .240 with a .298 on base percentage and struck out 157 times in 159 games.
The case for keeping him is much stronger. Adell finished the year with 23 home runs, 26 doubles and 94 RBIs, and he was even better after arriving in Cleveland at the trade deadline. In 48 games with the Guardians, he hit .244 with a .324 on base percentage, seven home runs and 32 RBIs. His .740 OPS and 108 OPS+ made him an above average hitter, and he launched some of the longest home runs any Cleveland player hit all season.
He also filled a specific need. The Guardians ranked 27th in baseball in home runs, and their lineup leans heavily on left-handed hitters. Adell gave Stephen Vogt a right-handed power threat in the middle of the order, something Steven Kwan said the team had been missing for a long time. Adell has a track record of producing that power, too, after hitting 37 home runs with 98 RBIs for the Angels in 2025.
Replacing that production on the open market would almost certainly cost more than $9.6 million, especially with right-handed power so scarce around the league. Chris Antonetti has also said Cleveland’s payroll will go up next season, so the money should be there.
The more likely non-tender candidates are Colin Holderman, David Fry and Blake Perkins. Adell should not be part of that conversation. He just got married over the weekend, and if Noga is right, he will spend 2027 back in the middle of Cleveland’s lineup.
NEXT: One Reason To Be Concerned About Parker Messick’s October Struggles








