Ever since he won the left field job in 2022 after a brilliant spring, Cleveland Guardians outfielder Steven Kwan has been a big part of four postseason runs in five years. He has won four Gold Gloves and gone to two All-Star Games as a member of the team.
Of course, he has also been linked with a trade out of Cleveland almost every year. And every season, the organization decides to keep him despite historically taking advantage of talented players on the market, selling high before they hit free agency.
Those who want to maximize potential value would like to see the Guardians trade Kwan. There are many logical reasons to do so.
However, there are also reasons not to flip him to another team. One, however, stands out above the rest:
Finding A Reliable Alternative Will Be Expensive And Unrealistic
Kwan has been a major leaguer for five full seasons now, starting in 2022. He has racked up 18.7 fWAR over that time: just 26 position players have more in the entire league. That means, if we had to do a draft based on fWAR output over the last five years, Kwan would be a first-round pick.
Kwan isn’t flashy because he doesn’t have 15-homer power, but few hitters have his knowledge of the strike zone on top of elite bat-to-ball skills. This season, the dynamic leadoff man finished with a .282 batting average and an impressive .382 OBP despite a rough first half that turned a huge portion of the fan base against him.
Remember, the Guardians are one or two pieces away from being World Series contenders. Subtracting Kwan from the mix would create a need to replace him with a reliable alternative, and it’s hard to think of affordable ones who might fit.
Kwan is Cleveland’s leadoff hitter, a Gold-Glove-caliber outfielder in both left and center, and an on-base machine, in addition to a respected clubhouse guy. How do you find that for an affordable salary, or without giving up important prospect capital?
Yes, the Guardians might lose Kwan for nothing after the 2027 World Series. However, at this point, his projected return in a hypothetical trade probably wouldn’t make up for the fact that he will be sorely missed in the lineup, on the field, and in the clubhouse. Keeping him might be the best course of action.
NEXT: Parker Messick’s Heater Put Him In Elite Company This Season








