Chris Antonetti made it clear at the General Managers Meetings that the Cleveland Guardians want to add a starting pitcher this winter. Now MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand has a suggestion for who it should be. Feinsand picked one free agent fit for every team in baseball, and for Cleveland, he chose a pitcher the Guardians know very well. Casey Mize spent nearly his entire career with the Detroit Tigers before a deadline trade sent him to San Diego, and he is now a free agent.
“The Guardians are familiar with Mize from his time in the AL Central — he has a 2.41 ERA in six career starts against them — and while his late-season stint with the Padres didn’t go well (7.46 ERA in 10 starts), he was superb with the Tigers during the first four months and would fit nicely in Cleveland’s rotation,” Feinsand wrote.
Feinsand pointed out that Mize has a 2.41 ERA in six career starts against the Guardians. Cleveland has seen plenty of him over the years, and it has rarely been fun for the lineup.
His 2026 season was a story of two very different halves. With Detroit, Mize was outstanding. He made 16 starts and posted a 2.70 ERA with a 0.99 WHIP, striking out 85 batters in 86 2/3 innings. His 156 ERA+ ranked among the best marks in the American League over that stretch.
Then the Tigers traded him to the Padres, and things fell apart. Mize went 2-4 with a 7.46 ERA in 10 starts for San Diego, allowing 56 hits in 44 2/3 innings. Feinsand acknowledged that stretch did not go well, but believes his first four months in Detroit show what he can still be. Overall, he finished 6-10 with a 4.32 ERA and 110 strikeouts in 131 1/3 innings.
The year before was even better. Mize earned his first All-Star selection in 2025, going 14-6 with a 3.87 ERA over 28 starts. Over his career, he owns a 4.22 ERA with 475 strikeouts in 571 1/3 innings.
Mize carries plenty of pedigree, too. The Tigers made him the first overall pick in the 2018 draft out of Auburn, and he debuted against the White Sox in August 2020. His career was derailed when he needed Tommy John surgery and missed all of 2023, but he worked his way back and has been a regular member of a big league rotation for three straight seasons.
The fit in Cleveland makes sense. Foster Griffin is a free agent after throwing 172 2/3 innings this season, and the rest of the rotation behind Gavin Williams and Parker Messick comes with questions. Tanner Bibee is coming off an inconsistent year, Daniel Espino’s role is still undecided and Joey Cantillo and Slade Cecconi are rebuilding their workloads as starters. A durable veteran like Mize would add stability.
Mize turns 30 in May, and his rough finish in San Diego could keep his price lower than it might have been in August. That is exactly the kind of buy low opportunity this front office has taken advantage of before. Cleveland’s pitching staff has a long track record of helping talented arms get back on track.
If the Guardians can get the version of Mize who dominated in Detroit for four months, he could be one of the best additions of the winter. He has given Cleveland’s hitters fits for years, and having him on their side would be a welcome change.
NEXT: Analyst Proposes Blockbuster Trade Between Guardians And Giants







