Steven Kwan’s name has been floating around trade rumors for months, and analysts keep finding new homes for him. The latest idea sends the Cleveland Guardians outfielder to the West Coast. Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly put together a list of five unpopular trades that could happen this offseason, and one of them has Kwan heading to the San Francisco Giants. In return, Cleveland would get infielder Casey Schmitt, a right-handed bat with years of team control left.
Proposed trade:
Guardians receive: Casey Schmitt
Giants receive: Steven Kwan
“Buster Posey and the Giants could use Kwan’s presence in their lineup as they try to rebound from consecutive disappointing seasons. Casey Schmitt is coming off of a second half where he posted just a .582 OPS, but he still has three arbitration years before free agency and crushes lefties. Schmitt could get at-bats at a variety of positions, including first base, left field and DH for the Guardians,” Kelly wrote.
Kelly’s reasoning starts with the calendar. Kwan is entering his final year of arbitration, with a projected salary of about $11.3 million, and could be looking at a deal worth more than $100 million next winter. Kelly noted that the Guardians seriously considered trading Kwan before the 2025 deadline, and that Chris Antonetti left himself some wiggle room in October. Antonetti pointed out that Cleveland has handled players in Kwan’s situation in different ways over the years, though he said the club expects Kwan to be a big part of a contending team in 2027.
The timing also lines up with Kwan’s production. He hit just .225 with a .614 OPS in the first half of 2026, then exploded after the All Star break, hitting .353 with an .875 OPS to become one of the best players in baseball. He finished the season with a .282 average, a .382 on-base percentage, 85 walks and 5.3 WAR. Selling high after a second half like that would make sense for a front office that likes to maximize value.
For San Francisco, the fit is clear. The Giants are trying to bounce back from consecutive disappointing seasons, and Kelly believes Kwan would thrive at Oracle Park. Its huge outfield, including the gap in right-center known as Triples Alley, would suit a four-time Gold Glover who was also a finalist in center field this year.
Schmitt is the more interesting piece for Guardians fans. He has played second base, shortstop, third base and first base in the majors, and the Giants started using him in left field this season. Kelly suggested Cleveland could use him at first base, in left field or at designated hitter, three spots where the Guardians need help.
His season was a tale of two halves. Through late May, Schmitt was hitting .293 with an .866 OPS and nine home runs, the best mark among Giants regulars, and his hard hit rate was a career high. Kelly noted that he slumped to a .582 OPS after the break. For his career, he has a .715 OPS against left-handed pitching with 13 home runs, and Cleveland’s lineup struggled badly against lefties this year.
Still, the return feels light. Schmitt is a useful player, but Kwan was one of the most valuable outfielders in the American League this season, and Cleveland is coming off a trip to the ALCS. It is easy to see why Kelly labeled this deal unpopular.
For now, Antonetti’s comments suggest Kwan is staying. If the Guardians do decide to make a move, they will likely want far more than Schmitt in return.
NEXT: 2 Guardians Players Projected To Have Expanded Roles In 2027







