The Cleveland Guardians face a dilemma behind the plate as they navigate the final weeks of the 2025 season.
With their offense struggling to generate runs, catcher has become a point of concern.
The team is weighing defensive reliability against the need for improved offense from that spot in the lineup.
Analyst Bruce Drennan recently voiced his frustration about the current situation, particularly regarding Bo Naylor’s struggles.
“I’ve got concerns about Naylor. How long do we go with him? The offense has got to be improved, and it’s just not there. [Austin] Hedges is a good defensive catcher, and a mentor, and clubhouse presence, but come on, you’ve got to score runs,” Drennan said.
Is catcher the biggest offesason NEED for the #Guardians? #GuardsBall
"I've got concerns about Naylor, how long do we go with him."
-Bruce
Presented by #mentornissan https://t.co/ouNQklEmQD pic.twitter.com/5OOmsVbiJ0
— Bruce Drennan Show (@Bruce_Drennan) September 2, 2025
This tension reflects a broader challenge facing the Guardians as they balance multiple priorities.
Naylor has earned recognition for his work behind the plate and his ability to handle the pitching staff. However, his bat tells a different story over his 105 games.
He is hitting .177 with limited power numbers.
He made mechanical adjustments during the season, switching from a leg kick to a toe tap approach. Those changes showed promise during a four-hit performance last month, but consistency remains elusive.
Meanwhile, Hedges’ defensive skills and clubhouse leadership provide value that extends beyond traditional statistics, though his offensive numbers are modest (.147 batting average).
The Guardians rank near the bottom of MLB in team batting average, making every offensive contribution critical.
This reality puts additional pressure on the catcher to deliver more production.
Moving forward, the front office will likely prioritize this position.
Whether through player development, trades or free agents, addressing the catching situation could be key to improving both lineup balance and overall competitiveness.
NEXT: Steven Kwan Is Quietly Getting Back To Form
