Generally speaking, the Cleveland Guardians roster is in a good place heading into the offseason. Granted, the current inactivity can be frustrating, but this is a team that just went to the AL Championship Series and maintains the same core. There are moves to be made, yes, but a roster overhaul isn’t needed.
Some of the pieces on the roster, however, are not without risks. The following two players in particular have some red flags that warrant some concern:
Tanner Bibee
The Guardians have said all the right things about Tanner Bibee. They say they expect him to be a key cog on their 2027 rotation and beyond. However, the lack of trust in his ability to dominate top offenses and keep the ball in the park is evident.
The guy pitched 0.1 innings in the postseason. He had an ERA over 7.00 in September. And his ERA and home run total have both increased in every year he has pitched in the league.
Bibee still has a 3.82 career ERA, so he knows how to pitch. He has been successful before, and there’s hope that he can turn things around. It’s far from a given, though, especially as his fastball loses power and velocity.
The Guardians would be ecstatic even if he settles in that 3.80-ERA range, but the last two years have shown us that things can get really ugly at times. The talent is there, but so are the red flags.
Kyle Manzardo
Kyle Manzardo started the 2026 campaign as Cleveland’s starting first baseman. He earned that right after his breakout 2025 season in which he homered 27 times and posted a 112 wRC+, comfortably above the league-average threshold of 100.
His 2026 was rather forgettable, though. He was mired in an ugly slump for most of the early stages of the season, improved a bit, and found himself optioned to Triple-A after effectively being replaced by Nathaniel Lowe at the deadline.
Manzardo remains part of the roster, but he needs to show that his 2026 campaign was a fluke and not the rule. Some concerning underlying stats explain his slump, most notably his alarmingly high 32 percent strikeout rate.
He wasn’t that bad in the end, as he finished his year with a 94 wRC+. That’s not going to cut it in the future, though, not with Ralphy Velazquez waiting in the wings.
Manzardo, when he’s right, offers power and patience from the left side of the plate, but he strikes out too much, is a liability against lefties, and offers little defensive or baserunning value. There are reasons to be concerned about his future role on the team.
NEXT: Guardians Announce Shocking David Fry Decision








