The Cleveland Guardians’ latest promotional giveaway is sparking plenty of debate among fans.
The team recently announced that a Rajai Davis 2016 Game 7 bobblehead will be given away on May 16 against the Cincinnati Reds. The moment commemorated? Davis’ unforgettable, game-tying home run in the eighth inning of Game 7 of the 2016 World Series.
If you’re a Guardians fan, you remember it instantly.
Down 6-4 to the Chicago Cubs in Game 7, Davis launched a dramatic two-run homer off Aroldis Chapman to tie the game at 6-6. Progressive Field erupted. It remains one of the most iconic swings in franchise history.
On this date seven years ago today! #RajaiDavis #Indians #WorldSeries pic.twitter.com/yqZhZeqQK3
— Cleveland Sports Talk (@CLEsportsTalk) November 2, 2023
But here’s where the controversy comes in.
The Guardians lost that game.
The Cubs ultimately won Game 7 in extra innings, 8-7, ending Cleveland’s championship hopes in heartbreaking fashion. While Davis’ home run is forever etched into baseball lore, it came in a losing effort.
And some fans aren’t thrilled about celebrating it.
The criticism centers on whether it’s appropriate to memorialize a moment from a World Series that ended in defeat. For some, the pain of 2016 still lingers. That series was as close as Cleveland has come to winning a World Series since 1948. The image of Davis rounding the bases is inseparable from the rain delay, the extra innings, and the final out that sealed the Cubs’ victory.
“I realize it was an iconic moment, but we didn’t win,” Tony Rizzo said.
"I realize it was an iconic moment, but we didn't win," – Rizz is confused why the Guardians are giving away a bobblehead to celebrate a game they lost.
Do you agree? pic.twitter.com/JFDACIZcxX
— ESPN Cleveland (@ESPNCleveland) February 18, 2026
From that perspective, a Game 7 bobblehead feels like reopening an old wound.
The 2016 Guardians battled injuries all postseason. They pushed a 103-win Cubs team to the brink. They forced a Game 7. And for a few electric minutes in the eighth inning, the city believed.
Promotional giveaways often tap into nostalgia. And while 2016 ended painfully, it also represents one of the proudest stretches in franchise history. It united the fan base and created memories that still resonate nearly a decade later.
Still, emotions surrounding that series are complicated.
Some fans would likely prefer bobbleheads tied to division titles, current stars, or postseason victories rather than a moment that ultimately came up short. Others see it as honoring one of the most dramatic swings ever hit in a Cleveland uniform.
The reaction has been mixed — passionate, as you would expect.
One thing is certain: people are talking about it.
And whether fans view it as a tribute to an iconic moment or a reminder of heartbreak, the Rajai Davis Game 7 bobblehead ensures that May 16 at Progressive Field will carry a little extra emotion.
NEXT: Guardians Given Stunning 2026 World Series Projection
