The Cleveland Guardians had to protect some players from being exposed to the Rule 5 Draft, which is usually in December, but its 2026 status remains up in the air due to the looming lockout. The way to make sure these prospects are not taken is by adding them to the 40-man roster.
On Tuesday, the Guardians added pitcher Justin Campbell, catcher Kody Huff, and outfielder Jaison Chourio to their roster, thus showing faith in their future and their projection. With that move, Cleveland’s roster is now full at 40 players.
Due to the roster crunch, the organization left some guys they value unprotected. Such is the case of left-handed pitcher Franklin Gomez.
Gomez is a talented 21-year-old pitcher who spent most of the 2026 campaign in High-A before reaching Double-A. He is a starter and pitched 74.2 innings between the two levels with a 3.25 ERA.
Analyst Justin Lada expressed mild surprise after watching the Guardians fail to protect Gomez, who might get taken in the draft if it ends up happening. He said, however, that the organization might believe he is not particularly close to the majors.
“A little surprised the Guardians didn’t protect Franklin Gomez. But they may think he’s far enough away that they don’t need to make a roster move to add him. And there may not be a Rule 5 draft anyway,” Lada posted.
A little surprised the Guardians didn't protect Franklin Gomez. But they may think he's far enough away that they don't need to make a roster move to add him. And there may not be a rule 5 draft anyway
— Justin L. (jlbaseball on bluesky) (@JL_Baseball) November 17, 2026
First of all, depending on what the players’ union and the league decide, there might not be a Rule 5 Draft, as Lada explains. Additionally, Gomez still hasn’t mastered the high minors, as he put up a solid 3.78 ERA in Double-A, but the sample size, 16.2 innings, wasn’t terribly large.
If a team picks up a player in the major league portion of the Rule 5 Draft, he needs to be kept on the MLB roster all year. Otherwise, he ought to be offered back to his old team.
Being so far away from helping in the majors, taking Gomez as a bet for 2027 only would be a risk, even for rebuilding squads. That’s probably what the Guardians thought before leaving him unprotected.
Gomez, who posted a 3.10 ERA in 58 frames in High-A with 66 punchouts, is a promising hurler but will still need some time to finish his development phase. Cleveland hopes that process can still happen with them.
NEXT: Analyst Points Out 2 Notable Guardians Roster Omissions








