Injuries, slumps, and other circumstances can get in the way of established stars showing their best form. The Cleveland Guardians have some players who could definitely serve as examples of this.
These three ballplayers enter the offseason with a lot of work to do, as they have things to prove in 2027:
Jose Ramirez
During the 2026 playoffs, Jose Ramirez returned to his best and carried the Guardians. He hit .293 with a 152 wRC+, two home runs, three stolen bases, and eight RBI in 11 October games. So why is he on this list? Well, because he needs to show over a long, sustained period that he can still be the guy to lead Cleveland.
Ramirez is 34 now, and before breaking his hamate bone in June, he had a 110 wRC+: not bad, but far from his career 127 mark. His final 92 wRC+ can be, in large part, explained by his wrist injury, because he was abysmal for weeks in the summer and the stretch run before turning it on in the postseason. However, it’s fair to wonder whether he had started to decline in the first three months before his injury.
So, to sum up, Ramirez has something to prove next year. People are wondering whether his final numbers in the regular season were the result of the injury, decline, or both.
Tanner Bibee
Bibee’s pride must have been affected after pitching just 0.1 innings in the postseason. However, as we have said many times in this space, the team had plenty of reasons to question his ability to perform in the postseason.
For starters, his ERA has been trending in the wrong direction since his rookie year. It was 4.36 in 2026, and he also surrendered a career-high 29 home runs. He was also awful in September, with an ERA flirting with 8.00.
Questions about his fastball and, as a result, his ability to keep the ball in the park are still very much unanswered with a long-term view in mind. There has been some trade chatter involving the talented, yet inconsistent right-hander, but so far, the organizational stance has been clear: he is expected to be a big part of the 2027 rotation.
Kyle Manzardo
Everybody is already counting on Ralphy Velazquez to break camp with the Guardians as their first baseman, now that Nathaniel Lowe is a free agent. However, Kyle Manzardo is still expected to be part of the mix in 2027.
Demoted in August after the Lowe trade, Manzardo wrapped up the regular season with a 94 wRC+ and just 13 home runs, down from 27 and 112 in 2025, respectively. The organization knows he can be much better than what he showed this year, and will absolutely give him a shot to redeem himself in the spring.
Cutting the strikeouts (32 percent in 2026) would be a good way to start. Hitting the ball with authority more often would help, too.
A healthy, locked-in Manzardo definitely belongs in the Guardians lineup either as a first baseman or as a designated hitter.
NEXT: 3 Guardians Who Could Experience A Power Spike In 2027







