Parker Messick’s breakout rookie season is already paying off for the Cleveland Guardians in more ways than one. The left-hander was named a finalist for the AL Cy Young Award on Monday after going 12-9 with a 2.56 ERA and 193 strikeouts over 186 1/3 innings. That honor does more than put Messick in the running for hardware. Because he finished in the top three of the voting as a former top prospect in his first full season, Cleveland will receive an extra selection in next summer’s draft. Justin Lada broke down what that means, noting that Messick is “netting the Guardians a PPI pick in the 2027 draft.”
“With Parker Messick netting the Guardians a PPI pick in the 2027 draft they are now looking at something like this 1.26 (1st round) 1.30 (Parker Messick Cy Young PPI) 2.60 (this is guaranteed for Logan Schmidt loss I believe) Comp B (after round 2 – something in the 60-70 range),” Lada wrote.
With Parker Messick netting the Guardians a PPI pick in the 2027 draft they are now looking at something like this
1.26 (1st round)
1.30 (Parker Messick Cy Young PPI)
2.60 (this is guaranteed for Logan Schmidt loss I believe)
Comp B (after round 2 – something in the 60-70 range)— Justin L. (jlbaseball on bluesky) (@JL_Baseball) November 3, 2026
PPI stands for Prospect Promotion Incentive, a rule added in the last collective bargaining agreement to reward teams for promoting their top prospects instead of holding them back for service time reasons. If a player who appeared on preseason top 100 lists spends a full rookie season in the majors and then wins Rookie of the Year or finishes in the top three of MVP or Cy Young voting, his team gets an extra pick after the first round. Messick qualifies no matter who wins the Cy Young on Nov. 11. Houston landed a PPI pick at No. 28 this past summer after Hunter Brown finished third in the 2025 AL Cy Young race.
Lada laid out how the extra pick fits into Cleveland’s full haul. The Guardians are projected to have their own first-round pick around No. 26, followed by the Messick PPI pick around No. 30. They also own the No. 60 pick as compensation for failing to sign Logan Schmidt, their second round selection from 2026. On top of that, Cleveland should have a Competitive Balance Round B pick that falls somewhere in the 60 to 70 range.
In a follow up post, Lada noted he had left out Cleveland’s regular second-round pick. That gives the Guardians five selections in roughly the top 75 picks, an unusually large draft class for a team that just won its division.
The Schmidt situation turned a disappointment into an opportunity. Cleveland drafted the hard throwing left hander out of Ganesha High School in Pomona, California, with the 59th pick in July, but the two sides could not agree on a bonus before the signing deadline. Schmidt chose to keep his commitment to LSU, and the Guardians got the pick back one spot later in 2027.
All of this could matter a lot for an organization that builds through the draft. Gavin Williams, Chase DeLauter and Travis Bazzana were all first-round picks, and Messick and Tanner Bibee were taken out of college as well. With more picks near the top of the draft, Cleveland will also have a larger bonus pool to work with, which gives the front office more flexibility to land the players it wants.
There is one caveat. The current CBA expires on Dec. 1, and draft rules could change in the next agreement. If the system stays in place, though, the Guardians are set up for one of their most important drafts in years, and Messick’s rookie season will be a big reason why.
NEXT: Stephen Vogt Gets Snubbed For Major MLB Award
