MLB roster decisions are tough enough as it is, based on the talent of the players and the needs of the team alone. If you add other concerns into the mix, such as minor league options and Rule 5 considerations, it can become even more difficult.
The Cleveland Guardians are facing that kind of dilemma as they look to finalize their 26-man roster for the 2026 season. Relief pitcher Peyton Pallette has put forth a strong case to make the team, and he also may have something else working in his favor.
Pallette was a Rule 5 draft pick by Cleveland, which means he has to be kept on the active roster for the entire season or be offered back to his previous team, which in this case is the Chicago White Sox. The Guardians must determine if Pallette can contribute enough to the pitching staff to be worth that restrictive requirement.
Guardians executive Bob DiBiasio recently said the team does not want to lose the young pitcher, but he also acknowledged that there may not be a role for him in its deep bullpen.
“I think [Peyton Pallette’s] got a really good chance. He’s throwing the heck out of the ball. I think he’s a guy we don’t want to lose. Our bullpen’s deep,” DiBiasio said.
Will Peyton Pallette make the Guardians' Opening Day roster or get shipped home? @BDbaseball6 sings Pallette's praises as we gear up for the start of the season. pic.twitter.com/NZxLKDI4i6
— Bruce Drennan Show (@Bruce_Drennan) March 16, 2026
A second-round pick by the White Sox in the 2022 MLB Draft, Pallette has not yet made his major league debut. He pitched last season at Double-A and Triple-A, where combined he threw 64.2 innings in 57 appearances with a 4.06 ERA, 86 strikeouts and just 28 walks.
According to MLB Pipeline, his fastball can hit 98 mph. After experiencing some shoulder tightness at the start of camp, he has eight strikeouts in just four innings and has not allowed a run in four spring training games. That alone could earn him a bullpen job.
However, other factors may be in play as well. Top setup man Hunter Gaddis has experienced forearm tightness, and though it is not believed to be serious, an extended absence could provide an opening and a need in the bullpen. But, if Joey Cantillo does not earn a spot in the starting rotation, he may be kept on as a reliever because he is out of minor league options.
It is a complicated situation, but if Pallette keeps pitching as he has been, he will make the decision very easy for the Guardians’ brass.
NEXT: Analyst Reveals Why He's 'Nervous' About 2026 Guardians
