The Cleveland Guardians did not make the loudest move of the offseason, but Rhys Hoskins could end up being one of their most important additions.
According to MLB.com’s Tim Stebbins, Hoskins is the type of player who can immediately raise Cleveland’s offensive floor, particularly in one area that hurt the team last season.
The numbers tell the story.
“The Guardians slashed .224/.290/.357 against lefties in 2025, which ranked 28th, 27th and 24th in the Majors, respectively. Hoskins has a career .243/.382/.501 slash line against southpaws, which includes a .221/.324/.407 line over 102 plate appearances last year. Put another way: Hoskins’ .731 OPS against lefties in 2025 was a career low, but still would have ranked third among Guardians who batted from the right side (minimum 100 plate appearances). At the very least, Hoskins should raise the floor here, and his presence will help against the division rival Tigers,” Stebbins wrote.
That is where Hoskins comes in.
Over his career, Hoskins has posted a .243/.382/.501 slash line against left-handed pitching. Even in what was considered a down year by his standards in 2025, he still recorded a .221/.324/.407 line over 102 plate appearances against lefties. His .731 OPS against southpaws last season was actually a career low.
Yet even that “career low” production would have ranked third among right-handed Guardians hitters with at least 100 plate appearances in 2025.
Cleveland does not necessarily need Hoskins to be an All-Star-level performer to justify the move. They simply need him to stabilize an obvious weakness. Against division rivals like the Detroit Tigers, who feature quality left-handed pitching, having a proven right-handed bat in the middle of the lineup could make a real difference.
Hoskins also gives manager Stephen Vogt flexibility at first base and designated hitter. He can be deployed strategically in favorable matchups while allowing younger hitters like Kyle Manzardo to continue developing without carrying the full burden of production against every type of pitching.
The signing may not grab national headlines, but it addresses a specific problem.
For a team trying to close the gap in the division, that kind of steady upgrade could matter more than it first appears.
NEXT: Chris Antonetti Isn’t Shying Away From Big Expectations
