The Cleveland Guardians pulled off a remarkable comeback, erasing a 15.5-game deficit to overtake the Detroit Tigers and secure the AL Central title.
Critics might point to their 88-74 record and minus-6 run differential as evidence of luck, but Cleveland thrived in close games and high-pressure situations.
The offense struggled significantly, ranking 28th in runs scored and exposing persistent issues at the plate that demand attention heading into the offseason.
Pressure has mounted for the Guardians to address these weaknesses, with many calling for meaningful upgrades while protecting the organization’s young talent pipeline.
“Fix the offense… if you can. The Guardians have sucked at hitting for years. But that’s the past, not the future. DeLauter, Valera, Kayfus, and Bazzana are all promising, and Fry could be really good if fully healed, too. Add some pieces but don’t block the rookies,” per Always the Jake.
Take #1: Fix the offense… if you can.
The Guardians have sucked at hitting for years. But that's the past, not the future. DeLauter, Valera, Kayfus, and Bazzana are all promising, and Fry could be really good if fully healed, too.
Add some pieces but don't block the rookies.
— Always the Jake (@JacobsFieldRBW) October 3, 2025
José Ramírez anchored the lineup with another elite season, ranking fifth in baseball in OPS and becoming the only 30-40 player in 2025.
Kyle Manzardo emerged as a reliable cleanup hitter against right-handed pitching, posting a solid first half before accelerating after the All-Star break to finish with 27 home runs.
His breakout performance gives Cleveland a building block, though questions remain about his ability to handle left-handers moving forward.
A promising group of prospects, including Chase DeLauter, Travis Bazzana, George Valera, and C.J. Kayfus represents the future, but injuries and inconsistent results have delayed their impact.
Beyond Ramírez at third base, the infield remains unsettled with Rocchio, Arias, and Daniel Schneemann competing for roles without clear answers.
The outfield offers similar uncertainty outside of Steven Kwan’s established presence in left field.
Schneemann provides defensive flexibility, while Angel Martínez split time between center and second base during a forgettable campaign.
Bo Naylor’s strong September showing, posting 16 RBI and an .872 OPS, strengthens his case to remain the primary catcher.
Jones and Kayfus will battle for opportunities in spring training, though neither gained significant ground during their 2025 seasons.
Cleveland must balance immediate upgrades with long-term development as they build toward sustained contention.
NEXT: Former Player Reveals What Surprised Him About Brayan Rocchio's Season
