MLB owners and the players’ association (MLBPA) are currently in a standoff during negotiations for the new Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA). If an agreement isn’t reached before December 1, the league is expected to lock out the union, freezing any transactions until there’s a new deal.
While the players might be open to a salary floor, they strongly oppose a cap. On the other hand, the owners said on Wednesday, through Commissioner Rob Manfred, that they won’t sanction a CBA without both a floor and a cap.
This affects all squads. Some, like the Los Angeles Dodgers and the New York Mets, would have to find ways to cut some salary, and others, such as the Tampa Bay Rays or the Cleveland Guardians, would need to come up with creative ways to add some payroll without messing up team chemistry.
According to numbers thrown around in recent days, the Guardians would need to get to work if a salary floor is implemented.
“The league’s most recent proposal included a $258.2 million salary cap and a floor of $180.2 million, a system that would not be implemented until the 2028 season. Based on end-of-season payrolls from 2026, 12 clubs (Marlins, Guardians, Cardinals, Rays, Nationals, White Sox, Twins, Rockies, Pirates, Athletics, Reds and Brewers) would be required to increase payroll by a combined $636 million to meet the floor,” MLB insider Mark Feinsand wrote.
The Guardians ranked last in MLB with a $74 million payroll in 2026, showing that small-market teams can find success with modest expenses. The league, however, wants each squad to spend a minimum amount of money every year, and while Cleveland will inevitably increase its payroll for 2027, it would still need to add a lot to get to that $180.2 million proposal in case it is implemented. It wouldn’t have to be right away, though, since that specific arrangement would be enforced starting in 2028 if approved.
This measure would effectively force these teams to spend more, and as a result, in the specific case of the Guardians, there might be an ownership change in the not-so-distant future. Of course, this is all hypothetical, because a new CBA is far from being finalized; in fact, we might be looking at weeks or even months of inactivity, judging by the way things are trending.
NEXT: 2 Backup Catchers That Could Interest The Guardians







