Steven Kwan has been the subject of trade rumors for most of the last two years, and this winter is no exception. The Cleveland Guardians outfielder is entering his final season before free agency, and analysts across the industry keep listing him as one of the top trade candidates in baseball. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand included him again in his breakdown of trade candidates at every position this week. Feinsand laid out the decision Cleveland faces, but he does not expect Kwan to be moved.
“We’re accustomed to Kwan’s name landing on lists of trade candidates, but with only one year of club control remaining prior to free agency, the Guardians must decide whether to try extending him, trade him or risk losing him for nothing more than a compensatory draft pick. The likelihood is that Kwan remains in Cleveland, but that doesn’t mean that teams won’t try to acquire him,” Feinsand wrote.
Feinsand explained that the Guardians have three paths with only one year of club control left. They can try to sign Kwan to an extension, trade him, or keep him and risk losing him in free agency for nothing more than a compensatory draft pick. Feinsand believes Kwan will most likely stay, though he expects plenty of teams to call anyway.
Each option comes with its own challenges.
An extension would be the most popular choice among fans, but it would not come cheap. Kwan could be looking at a deal north of $100 million next winter. Cleveland has made long-term commitments before, most notably to José Ramírez and more recently to Tanner Bibee, and Chris Antonetti has said the payroll is going up in 2027. A deal for Kwan would still be one of the largest in franchise history.
A trade would follow a familiar pattern. Cleveland moved Francisco Lindor and Shane Bieber before they reached free agency, and teams like the Giants, Phillies, Cubs, Mariners and Blue Jays have been linked to Kwan this offseason.
Holding Kwan through the season carries a new risk as well. MLB’s latest labor proposal would eliminate the qualifying offer system. If that change goes through, Cleveland might not even get a compensatory pick if Kwan walks after 2027.
Kwan’s value is not in question. He hit .282 with a .382 on base percentage, drew 85 walks against 62 strikeouts and was worth 5.3 WAR in 2026. His season was a tale of two halves. He hit .225 with a .614 OPS before the All Star break, then hit .353 with an .875 OPS afterward to become one of the best players in baseball down the stretch. He has four Gold Gloves, two All-Star selections and 22 WAR over his first five seasons.
He also fills a role Cleveland cannot easily replace. The Guardians ranked 24th in runs scored, and Kwan was their best table setter. He is projected to earn about $11.3 million in arbitration, up from $7.725 million last season, which is still a bargain for his production.
NEXT: New Guardians Catcher Could Already Have A Big Role Next Season







