Given the state of the catching market, the Cleveland Guardians would be better off trying to hammer out a deal with Austin Hedges. He knows the pitchers, the team philosophy, and is vastly improved as a hitter.
For these reasons, however, his price in free agency has gone significantly up. Retaining him will be a tough proposition, so the team should be scouting the market for help behind the plate.
Recently protected prospect Kody Huff could be considered for the backup spot, but in case he isn’t ready, these two options might be realistic:
Jake Rogers
Rogers spent time with four different organizations in 2026. He is not exactly an inspiring option at the plate, but is steady behind it and could, theoretically, do a good job backing up Patrick Bailey.
Rogers is a bad hitter, and there are many free agent catchers who offer more offensively. The Guardians, however, often prioritize defense, framing, throwing, blocking, and game-calling from their backup catcher, and the former White Sox can offer solid play in those departments.
Rogers had 0 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and 0 FRV (Fielding Run Value) in 429.1 innings behind the plate this past season, but he has been an asset in those metrics before and is much better than, say, Tyler Stephenson or James McCann, who offer poor defensive play.
Kyle Higashioka
Higashioka is a 36-year-old veteran with a strong track record of success as a backup catcher. He’s also had stints as a regular, and with a career wRC+ of 85 and a 94 mark in 2026, he could offer a similar offensive profile to that of 2026 Hedges.
Higashioka, however, might hold out for a more concrete role that offers him the chance to start. With Patrick Bailey on the roster, a timeshare would be the most logical arrangement if he lands in Cleveland.
The Texas Rangers declined his $7 million option for 2027, making him a free agent. Cleveland might have a chance to get him for a lower salary, but there will be competition for the former Yankee and Padre.
Higashioka has solid receiving skills, which would certainly appeal to the Guardians, but his ability to throw out baserunners is subpar. A flexor strain in his forearm ended his season in July, but he should be fully healthy by spring training.
NEXT: Chase DeLauter’s Unusual Training Routine Resurfaces After Award Win







